The Thin Man (1934)

2014 #120
W.S. Van Dyke | 87 mins | DVD | 1.33:1 | USA / English | U

The Thin ManProduced as a B-movie, but eventually nominated for four of the biggest Oscars (Picture, Actor, Director, Screenplay*), comedic detective mystery The Thin Man went on to spawn five sequels and a TV series (not to mention a radio series, a stage play, and a musical), as well as inspiring a host of similar comic-mystery B-movie series like the Saint and the Falcon.

Playing like a cross between an Agatha Christie mystery and a screwball comedy, it’s in fact based on a novel by Dashiell Hammett, author of The Maltese Falcon, The Glass Key, and other hard-boiled tales. This is definitely not one of those. The murder mystery is standard enough — a businessman has disappeared, but when his former secretary and lover is found dead, he’s the prime suspect — albeit with enough genuine suspects and twists to keep the viewer guessing. The real joy comes from the investigators: retired detective and alcohol fan Nick Charles (William Powell) and his rich, interested wife Nora (Myrna Loy). Plus their dog, Asta, who gets up to all kinds of mischief. Regular readers will know I’m half-sold on the film at that point.

The film luxuriates in the interactions between Powell and Loy, and between them and any other character. The plot regularly takes a back seat to the cast’s playfulness, which only the most mystery-focused viewer will find objectionable, because it’s so delightful. Acting drunk for the sake of comedy might seem like a cheap fallback, but Powell is on just the right side of the line to make it work flawlessly, especially in scenes that border on farce, Screwing aroundlike a Christmas party which is regularly interrupted by victims and suspects. Even the final scene, a rambling and none-more-Christie-like “gather all the suspects and reveal the answers” dinner party, seems natural because of the characterisation throughout the rest of the film. Loy’s part may not be quite as showy — as demonstrated by its failure to gain an Oscar nomination — but she’s an invaluable half of the double act.

Across the decades the detective story has transitioned to be a staple of television, with dozens of US dramas each churning out 22+ mysteries per year, not to mention all the British ones and, more recently here in the UK, European imports — you can’t move for a fleet of complex murder mysteries being solved on the gogglebox every day. It can make older movies that do the same thing feel less significant; less deserving of their big-screen status. Not so with ones like The Thin Man, which has so much more to offer besides the narrative and its revelations. Here a solid mystery, with potential to keep the viewer guessing, gives a structure on which to hang the real joys, which are provided by the central screwball-ish relationship. And the dog, of course.

5 out of 5

Read my reviews of all the Thin Man films on Thin Man Thursdays.

* It lost to the father of screwball comedy, It Happened One Night, in every category. ^

6 thoughts on “The Thin Man (1934)

  1. The Thin Man is pretty impressive for a movie shot in just 12 days.
    I could happily sit and watch Powell and Loy downing drinks and shooting one-liners back and forth for the running time of Lawrence of Arabia. And wouldn’t it be wonderful if all murder mysteries were solved over the course a large banquet dinner?

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Great write-up of a film I’ve enjoyed many times – there is of course a good boxset available that contains the full set of Thin Man films, and whilst the quality gently slides through the series the Powell-Loy combo is always good value. It’s the charm of the piece that really does it, and the crime story can be set aside for long passages in favour of interaction between the leads.It was made during the Great Depression and audiences must have loads of fun getting away from their difficult existences to take in the no worries, high living hi-jinks of Mr and Mrs Charles!

    Liked by 1 person

    • I’m sure someone could write a great psychological piece on the types of escapism people enjoy in times of (relative) hardship — in the Great Depression, the fun antics of the well-to-do; nowadays, superheroes.

      I’ve reached the fifth film, where there’s no hint of crime for literally half an hour — I began to wonder if they were even bothering! But you’re spot on, it coasts by completely amiably on the power of Powell & Loy.

      Liked by 1 person

      • It’s one of the things I find most fascinating about researching ‘classic’ movies, looking at the time in which they were made and seeing the impact that it might have had. I guess Westerns are the best exemplars, as there were thousands of them made and so many held allegorical content about what was going on whilst the films were being made – High Noon and its subtexts relating to the blacklists, for example.

        Very true about the Powell-Loy charm – why, even the kid (which can often be the death knell of a good screen partnership) can’t ruin it.

        Liked by 1 person

  3. Terrific review of a marvelous film. Powell and Loy are just so good together, the mystery is a bonus and it’s a good one. Yes, the series does dip a bit as it goes on but there’s not a poor movie among them.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.